- 29 minutes ago
Jharkhand Chief Minister Hemant Soren assured protesting students that their concerns would be addressed and appropriate action taken, while the BJP demanded a CBI investigation into the alleged examination paper leak, intensifying the political battle over the recruitment controversy.
Category
🗞
NewsTranscript
00:00Good evening, you're watching NewsTrack with me, Maria Shaquille from Delhi's Jantar Mantar to the streets of Jharkand's Ranchi.
00:06The script of student protests has repeated itself.
00:09Students demanding answers over recruitment examinations once again found themselves facing barricades, water cannons, tear gas and lattes as they
00:18marched towards the Vidhan Sabha.
00:20The visuals from Ranchi have now triggered a political storm.
00:24The BJP has launched a sharp attack on the Hemansurayan government, accusing it of using excessive force against protesting students.
00:33The Jharkand Mukti Morcha says the BJP is politicizing the agitation and has alleged that outsiders were brought in to
00:41create chaos.
00:43But leader of opposition in Lok Sabha, Rahul Gandhi, has sought Home Minister Amit Shah's resignation after the July 20th
00:50crackdown has offered condemnation,
00:53in putting his own alliance partner under pressure.
00:57So two student protests, two crackdowns, but beyond the BJP versus JMM battle, beyond the center versus opposition politics, the
01:06central question remains.
01:08What happens to the students whose examinations, careers and futures are at stake?
01:16Will the Sorain government give in to the students' demands, or will the streets of Ranchi once again become a
01:24battleground?
01:25Before I bring in the leader of opposition in Jharkand Assembly, Babu Lal Marandi, here's a report.
01:56They were just meters away from the Jharkand Assembly, and then came the latis, tear gas shells,
02:02and water cannons.
02:04After the water cannon started, the water cannon started to run here, and the water cannon started to run here.
02:12They were prepared to run tear gas on the streets, but the police stopped them immediately.
02:19The operation workers reached the police and took them to the police.
02:22And now, the water cannon started to run, look at the barricade on the deadlock, here's a dance, this is
02:29a protest.
02:30They are protesting, and these protesters are literally dancing on the water cannon.
02:35Now we see the fourth, fifth barricade, with the bar void, they removed everything.
02:39When the administrative officials were preparing to tear shells, they immediately cornered those officers.
02:46They mobbed literally those officials, and they ran away.
02:52After talks with the government failed on Sunday, protesting students decided to march towards the Vidan Sabha.
02:59Fasting student leader Devindranath Mato joined the students' march on a stretcher.
03:22But when the protesters breached multiple barricades and entered the Vidan Sabha premises, police resorted to water cannons, tear gas,
03:30and lati charge.
03:31Thank you very much.
04:04Several students were injured.
04:09BJP leaders, on the other hand, Gheera and Jharkand Chief Minister Hemanswarin's residence, demanding his resignation, with several leaders being
04:16detained as well.
04:37The protest continued into the evening, with students being subjected to a lati charge again.
04:42The politics over the police action has intensified.
04:46The BJP has condemned the police action on protesting students in Rajji.
04:50It questioned the opposition leaders who villainized Delhi police over pellet guns used and went silent on Jharkand police.
05:19The JMM, meanwhile, has accused the BJP of politicizing the agitation and alleged that outsiders were being brought in to
05:25create chaos.
05:40It's deja vu. We have seen this play out before.
05:43The moment a student protest turns violent, the debate shifts from the students' demands to allegations of outsiders and anti
05:50-social elements.
05:51But this time, there is another political message.
05:55Lok Sabha leader of opposition, Rahul Gandhi, has criticized his own ally.
05:59He has said that the use of force against protesting students in Jharkand is wrong.
06:17The leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha has spoken.
06:20And once again, he has put the ball in the center's court as the government faces questions over the July
06:2520th crackdown on students.
06:27It is learned that Home Minister Amit Shah is likely to speak on the students' protest in Parliament.
06:33Two protests, similar crackdowns, but very different political messaging.
06:38Yet, beyond the politics, there is one truth that cannot be lost in the noise.
06:43The students, the demand for fair and transparent recruitment exams.
06:47Their right to protest and their right to question any government.
06:51At Jhantar Mantar, the demand was for a minister's designation.
06:54The Modi government eventually gave in to the students' demand.
06:58In Jharkand, the students want the JPSC prelim and backlog exams cancelled.
07:02They are also demanding a CVI probe into alleged irregularities in the JSSC CGL examination.
07:08So the question now is simple.
07:10Will the Soran government listen?
07:13Or will the streets once again become the battleground between students and the Soran Sarkar?
07:17Because the real test for any government is not how it handles dissent when the streets are silent,
07:23but how it responds when students raise their voice.
07:26With Ashwath Ashmishra and Satyajit Kumar in Ranchi, Vira Report, India Today.
07:37Just a few minutes ago, Dharkand, Chief Minister Himan Sorain, has put out a tweet.
07:42And he has said that he is appealing to protesting students to maintain peace
07:46and has assured them that his government will act with seriousness and sensitivity on their demands.
07:52He has gone on to say that he thanks the police and the administration for handling today's student protests with
08:00restraint.
08:01Sorain has said that students have every right to raise their concerns in a democracy
08:06and that it is the government's responsibility to respect their voice.
08:10He said that senior ministers have been in continuous dialogue with the protesters
08:15and assured that steps will be taken to address their grievances
08:19and make the examination system more transparent,
08:23technology-driven and secure and accountable.
08:26Himan Sorain also accusing that some of the opposition leaders are trying to politicize the protests
08:33and he has urged students not to be misled by political narratives.
08:38He reiterated his appeal for dialogue and trust to resolve this issue.
08:45And joining me first on the show is Babu Lal Marandi,
08:49a leader of opposition of Dharkand Assembly.
08:52Mr. Marandi, I appreciate your time.
08:54In today's case, thank you for talking to me today.
09:40What will happen next?
10:12What will happen next?
10:40What will happen next?
11:10What will happen next?
12:10What will happen next?
12:40What will happen next?
13:05What will happen next?
13:39What will happen next?
13:41JMM والے کہہ رہے ہیں کہ BJP نوکری چانے والے یواؤں کے گصے کا راجنیتک فائدہ اٹھا رہی ہے.
13:48بجائے کوئی تھوس سمادہان پیش کرنے کے.
14:18بجائے سے جانچ کرائیں گے تو پھر کہاں کوئی ہمیں لاب اٹھانے کی ماملہ ہے اس کا لاب تو مکہ
14:26منتری کو سیدھا سیدھا ملے گا.
14:29اسی لیے یہ ہم کوئی راجنیتک فائدے کے لیے نہیں کر رہے ہیں.
14:32ہم جھارکھنڈ کے فائدے کے لیے جھارکھنڈ کی نوزوانوں کا جو حق بیچا گیا ہے اس میں ان نوزوانوں کو
14:40نیائے دلانے کے لیے ہماری پارٹی لڑ رہی ہے اور ان نوزوانوں کے ساتھ میں ہے۔
14:45بابلال جی آج چھاتروں پر لاتی چارج ہوا آنسو گیس کے گولے چھوڑے گئے پانی کی بوچار بھی کی گئی
14:54کچھ چھاتروں کو ہراست میں لیا گیا ہے تو آپ کیا آپ کو کیا لگتا ہے اس پردرشن میں آگے
15:01کیا ہوگا یہ پردرشن آگے کیسے جائے گا
15:06آگے ہم لوگ تائے کریں گے ابھی تو آگے کی ہم لوگ نے تائے نہیں کیا لیکن لگتا ہے کہ
15:11لڑائی لمبی لڑائی لڑنی پڑے گی سرکار سے
15:14آسانی سے سرکار ماننے والی نہیں ہے اب رانچی تک میں نہیں سمپون جھارکھنڈ بھی اس لڑائی کو ہم لوگوں
15:20نے اس کو فیلائیں گے
15:21تاکہ لوگ تانتر میں مالک جنتہ ہوتی ہے کہ ہم جنتہ کے بیچ بھی جائیں گے تاکہ لوگ سمجھے انہوں
15:28نے کس پرکار سے ایک ایک
15:29نوکری کو بیچا ہے کیسے ان لوگوں نے یہ دھندھا کیا ہے پوری طرح سے یہ ہمیں جنتہ کو بتانا
15:36ہے
15:37تو اس لڑائی کو ہم لوگ جھارکھن کی گاؤں گاؤں تک بھی لے جائیں گے اور دیس بیابے بھی لے
15:43جائیں گے کیسے
15:44ڈینڈی الائنس کے لوگ جہاں ان کی ستہ ہے اور وہاں کس پرکار سے یہ لوگ کروڑتا پر اتراتے ہیں
15:52جب سانتی پون دھرنا ہوتا ہے تو سرکار سنتی نہیں ہے
15:56اور ویدھان سبھا کی طرف جب لوگ کچھ کرتے سانتی پون ڈنگ سے تو ڈنڈے چلاتے ہیں
16:02میرا آخری سوال یہ ہوگا آپ سے کہ ابھی کچھ دیر پہلے راؤل گانڈی نے بھی چھاتروں کے سمبند میں
16:09بولا ہے
16:10اور بھاجپا کا کہنا ہے آپ یہ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ رانچی تک یہ پردرشن سیمت نہیں رہے گا
16:16اور پورے جھارکھن میں آپ پھیلائیں گے تو آگے کیا کریں گے آپ
16:22یہ سبحاویک ہے اب میں تو کہتا ہوں چھاتر کا ہی یہ معاملہ نہیں ہے جھارکھنڈ کا معاملہ ہے
16:27میں لوگوں سے بار بار کہتا ہم تو جنپرتینی دی ہیں پانچ سال کے لیے چونے جاتے ہیں
16:32پانچ سال میں ہمیں جنتہ کے عدالت میں ایکزام دینا ہوتا ہے
16:36لیکن آج جو لوگ پیسے کے بال پر کرمچاری اور پتہ دیکاری بڑھیں گے
16:41تو اگلے بیس پچیس تیس ورسوں تک جھارکھنڈ میں بھرسٹا چار کی رائتہ ہی پھیلائیں گے
16:47تو جھارکھنڈ کہاں جائے گا جھارکھنڈ پوری طرح سے بھرسٹا چار کی دلدل میں پس جائے گا
16:53اسی لیے یہ لڑائی صرف ان نوجوانوں کا ہی نہیں ہے صرف ہمارا ہی نہیں ہے
16:57یہ لڑائی جھارکھنڈ کی لوگوں کا ہے
17:01جھارکھنڈ کو بھرسٹا چار کی دلدل سے بچانے کا یہ لڑائی ہے
17:05اور اسی لیے اس لڑائی میں سمپن جھارکھنڈ کے لوگ ساتھ دے رہے ہیں
17:10اور آگے بھی آنے والا سمیں میں بھی لوگ دیں گے
17:14بابلال مراندی there, leader of opposition of Jharkand
17:17and also the first chief minister of the state
17:20appreciate your time, thank you for joining us
17:22joining me on the show tonight, Bavyar is the national spokesperson of the congress
17:27Tuhin Sinha representing the BJP
17:28and Chandan Kumar is a PhD research scholar
17:30and student leader who is part of this JPSC, JSSC, Niai Manj
17:38I want to begin with you Chandan
17:41اس طرح کا پردرشن آج ہوا ہے
17:43students پر لاتی چارج ہوئے
17:45آگے کیا آپ لوگوں نے بنایا ہے
17:48آگے کیا کرنے والے ہیں
17:50کیونکہ آپ نے سنا بابلال مراندی وہ کیا بول رہے تھے
17:52ان کا کہنا ہے کہ یہ بس اب
17:56رانچی تک نہیں سیمت رہے گا
17:58یہ پورے جھارکھنڈ میں وہ پھیلائیں گے
18:23چندر میں آپ کا آوڈیو فکس کروں گی
18:26میں اپنے پروڈیوسر کو بولوں گا کہ آپ کا آوڈیو فکس کریں کیونکہ اس میں problem ہے
18:29تب تک بھاویا can come in
18:31بھاویا
18:32you know
18:33questions are being raised as to
18:35why is the congress having double standards
18:37when it comes to about issues of the students
18:40if the students are lati charged in delhi the congress raises it
18:44but when they are lati charged in jharkhand
18:49then you are silent because you feel
18:51that this entire protest a section of it
18:53is being you know has the support of the bjp
18:57maria there are two arguments i would like to make here
19:01one you're comparing apples and oranges
19:04in delhi they were using pellet guns
19:08shock battens this is something
19:11no no what are apples and oranges
19:12no no no
19:12yeah that the jharkhand police did not use pellet guns
19:16for you to use the word double standard
19:18that means you are comparing the police brutality in delhi
19:22no i'm asking the reaction of the congress party
19:25i'm talking about the reaction of the congress party
19:27you can say that they are my alliance partner i will not take a stand
19:30if you let me complete yeah
19:34or you want to just keep talking or interrupting me
19:37or will you let me complete
19:40you're i said you're comparing apples and oranges
19:42because here they did not use pellet guns
19:45they did not use shock battens
19:46and also the leader of opposition
19:49national leader of opposition rahul gandhi
19:52has condemned even this force
19:55and if there is any police access in this
19:57we will make sure whoever is responsible
20:01will be taken to task
20:03and there will be justice
20:05second part
20:08when it comes to
20:11jpsc exams
20:12we need to understand one thing
20:14any public service commission
20:16is an independent constitutional body
20:18it doesn't come under the government
20:20but still
20:22jpsc
20:23the government has appointed cid
20:25and three members have resigned
20:27the chairperson of jpsc has been arrested
20:29along with 20 others
20:31the exam has been cancelled as well
20:33within one week all of this has happened
20:35and
20:36and
20:37any
20:40ma'am you can finish your point
20:43but they're saying they can't hear me
20:45no you can be heard loud and clear
20:47please go ahead
20:48okay
20:49so
20:5120 people have been arrested
20:52three people have resigned
20:54and the chairperson has also been arrested
20:56anything anymore
20:57we are open
20:59and
20:59the process is going on
21:01the dialogue is happening
21:02unlike in Delhi
21:03where they let
21:04on
21:05until
21:06the leader of opposition intervened
21:08they did
21:09prime minister did not even acknowledge this
21:12here the chief minister has acknowledged
21:13gotten into a dialogue
21:15with the students
21:15okay so there is a reaction
21:16there is a difference in the manner in which
21:18the political class has reacted
21:21to me
21:22tohin please come on the screen now
21:24let me take that question to tohin
21:26tohin the question here is
21:28that if the students
21:30and
21:31and
21:31and
21:32i'm seeing visuals
21:33they are equally dramatic
21:34in
21:35rachi
21:36students being
21:37water cannons used
21:38tear gas issued
21:40used
21:41you know
21:42lati charge against students
21:43protesting students
21:45you know
21:46here is himan soren saying that is
21:48a police acted
21:49in restraint
21:50but the question really is
21:52that
21:53when there
21:54when they knew in advance
21:55they knew well in advance
21:57that there will be a gherav
21:58of the assembly
22:00then why was
22:01this kind of brutality allowed
22:03against protesting students
22:07you know
22:07baria
22:08the
22:08the genuineness
22:09and the sincerity
22:10of
22:11the protest
22:12can be gauged by the fact
22:14that not a single policeman
22:16has been
22:17injured in the protest
22:18how many were injured
22:19in delhi
22:20good 250 policemen
22:22had suffered serious injuries
22:23so these students
22:24were extremely
22:25peaceful
22:26protesters
22:27they have been
22:28very focused
22:29in their demand
22:30what is their demand
22:31a two-fold demand
22:32to constitute
22:33to initiate
22:34a cbi inquiry
22:35and number two
22:36to
22:37to cancel
22:38the jpsc exams
22:39and mind you
22:40you know
22:41exam paper leak
22:42is one thing
22:43over here
22:43what jharkhand
22:44has witnessed
22:45in the last six years
22:46is continuous
22:47selling of seats
22:49so you know
22:50admit cards
22:50and large numbers
22:51are found
22:52from people
22:52who do not even
22:53appear in exams
22:55but who subsequently
22:56get the jobs
22:57the jpsc jobs
22:59which are meant
23:00for the extremely
23:01poor sections
23:01of society
23:02so if rahul gandhi
23:03has an iota
23:04of seriousness
23:05in him
23:06he should tell
23:07him and sorain
23:08that him and sorain
23:09should go for
23:11a cbi inquiry
23:12but instead
23:12you know
23:13when rahul gandhi
23:13is nailed
23:14he gives
23:14these sermonizing
23:15statements
23:16that police
23:17should be fair
23:18to the students
23:18and all of that
23:19why is rahul gandhi
23:20not gherowing
23:21the residents
23:22let bhavia respond
23:23bhavia respond
23:24to this
23:26bhavia respond
23:27to this
23:27will amit shah
23:29allow supreme court
23:30monitored committee
23:32as we demanded
23:32to hinsha
23:34of course
23:35cbi
23:35will be
23:36one second
23:36students have
23:38a demand
23:38for cbi
23:39the same
23:40way students
23:40have a demand
23:41for supreme
23:41court monitored
23:42committee
23:43right
23:43at the central
23:44level
23:44will amit shah
23:45allow that
23:47one second
23:48will amit shah
23:48allow that
23:49and what about
23:49the brutality
23:50in
23:50till now
23:52the home minister
23:53has not
23:54don't confuse
23:55cockroaches
23:56of its students
23:57cjp is a full
23:58pledged subsidiary
23:59of armadmi
24:00party
24:00and if congress
24:01is an iota
24:02and you are
24:02police not
24:03getting injured
24:03here the police
24:05are controlling
24:06violence
24:07you know
24:08argument
24:09i have a problem
24:11with that argument
24:11a student is a
24:12student
24:14irrespective of
24:14which political
24:15party
24:15or youth wing
24:18he belongs to
24:18and i don't
24:19think so
24:20it's a fair
24:20comparison
24:20this was a group
24:23of students
24:23who motivated
24:24other students
24:25i don't think
24:26so you can
24:26draw that
24:27parallel
24:27let's not
24:28draw that
24:29parallel
24:29please
24:29never call
24:30the students
24:30as anti-nationals
24:32or terrorists
24:32they are fighting
24:33for their right
24:34let me bring
24:36in the student
24:36let me put
24:37the spotlight
24:38on those
24:38who matter
24:39here
24:39that he
24:41is a
24:41someone who's
24:42part of
24:42these protests
24:42chandhan
24:43mujhe
24:43bitayye
24:44ke
24:44aap
24:44kya
24:44abhi
24:45kuch
24:45chhatra
24:45abhi
24:46bhi
24:46assembly
24:47ke
24:47parisar
24:48mein
24:48baithe
24:48wae
24:48hain
24:48ke
24:49sab
24:49ab
24:50nikal
24:50karke
24:50jhaan
24:51par
24:51ye
24:51stadion
24:52me
24:52waha
24:52pe
24:52a
24:52gaya
24:54aap
24:55baitana
24:56cha
24:56pat
24:56aap
24:56rat
24:56karke
24:59karke
25:00charrge
25:00ke
25:01who
25:01kya
25:04go
25:05yeah
25:05chak
25:06kya
25:06kya
25:06kya
25:07kya
25:20kya
25:21In this situation, we had to do the health care hospital
25:24and I wanted to say to the government that the government
25:27could concern for some Old East Nkria.
25:30It could be something we can't say for those people like
25:32Malo, Koila, Sona, Abraka, Oxite.
25:36But the change of the government's position
25:38that we fight against the system,
25:41we fight against the government,
25:42you don't fight against the government,
25:43the beneficial factor of it.
25:44Even when the government becomes a government in
25:46Japan, we're fighting against the government.
25:50All right, the problem is there. Really bad audio again, Chandan.
25:54You know, this has to be fixed before we can continue.
25:56Let me give the last 30 seconds to both you and Bhavya and Tuhin.
26:02Bhavya, you want to go first? 30 seconds, quickly.
26:08When it comes to Delhi, brutality, of course, jarkhand, if there is police excess.
26:14As we see, and as Tuhin Sinha said, yes, there are no attacks on police.
26:19Because police were inflicting violence there, here the police are stopping violence.
26:23Second point, Amit Shah so far has not shown a little bit of courage as Rahul Gandhi has.
26:31By mentioning jarkhand in his Chhatron Ki Guj.
26:35Although our government is there, he mentioned jarkhand.
26:38And today's press conference, he is condemning the violence.
26:42But did Amit Shah even have the announce of courage to come to parliament and make a statement?
26:4930 seconds.
26:50Tuhin now, please.
26:51Students protesting in Delhi?
26:54Bhavya, can you ask her to calm down?
26:56Yes, please, go ahead.
26:56Tomorrow, the question to Congress Party is, will Rahul Gandhi be present when Amit Shahji
27:02is on the floor of the House on the student issue?
27:05And, you know, it is going to be a comprehensive discussion.
27:08We have seen this pattern from the Congress Party.
27:11They provoke us that, you know, we are not prepared for the discussion.
27:13When we come for the discussion, they change the culture.
27:15Okay, let's see finally whether the discussion actually happens on the floor of the House tomorrow.
27:19So, Tuhin and Bhavya, really appreciate your time.
27:21Thank you so much for joining us.
27:23That's all from me on this edition of NewsTrack.
27:25Thanks so much for watching.
Comments